NYC Cookie Swap Re-Cap and Jam Filled Bow Tie Cookies

Last Friday was a fun and delicious day with friends old and new, when I joined a group of bloggers in NYC’s theater district for lunch and a cookie swap organized by Abby, Chris, Gail, and Maggy.

I’ve never been to a cookie swap before. Knowing that so many venerable bakers were going to be in attendance (like Gail, here with her cutie-pie Mitzi)…

…I was quite nervous about what to bring.

I decided to make two different cookies: one gluten-free and one gluten-full. These bow-ties are the ones that were gluten-full…they’re made with a very simple, rich dough and filled with delicious jam. I used a homemade rosemary-infused peach jam that I never got around to blogging about last summer, but you can use your favorite.

Make sure not to overfill these cookies: stick to the recommended 1/2 teaspoon of jam. I got a little overzealous and added more to a few of mine: they didn’t seal properly and opened up in the oven.

I think these are at once adorable and elegant, and they garnered lots of compliments. I’ll be posting the recipe for the gluten-free cookies I brought to the swap, really delicious iced ginger bars, later this week.

[cft format=0]

Print Recipe
No ratings yet

Jam Filled Bow-Tie Cookies

adapted from this recipe, which appears in the special Holiday Issue of Fine Cooking Magazine: Cookies, Brownies, Bars and More
Makes about 70 cookies


  • * 8 oz. organic cream cheese softened
  • * 1 cup 2 sticks unsalted organic butter, softened
  • * 2-1/2 cups organic all-purpose flour sifted, plus more for rolling out the dough
  • * approximately 3/4 cup good quality jam peach, apricot, or your favorite
  • * One large egg preferably organic and free-range, beaten
  • * powdered confectioners’ sugar, for dusting the finished cookies


  • 1. In the bowl of an electric mixer, or with a hand mixer, beat the cream cheese and butter until light and fluffy (about 3 minutes). Scrape down the bowl and paddle.
  • 2. With the mixer on low, add the flour gradually, beating well after each addition. Mix until a smooth dough forms.
  • 3. Turn dough out onto a work surface dusted with flour and knead briefly to form a ball. Divide the dough into three equal portions and wrap each in plastic or waxed paper. Flatten each piece of dough into a square and refrigerate overnight.
  • 4. Heat oven to 400°F. Line 3 cookie sheets with a silpat or parchment paper. Remove one piece of dough from the refrigerator and roll it out on a lightly floured surface into a 1/8-inch-thick rectangle. Trim the rough edges of the dough so the sides are straight, and so the piece of dough measures 8 inches by 8 inches. Cut dough into 2-inch squares.
  • 5. Spoon 1/2 teaspoon of jam onto the center of each square. Fold one corner into the center, dab with the beaten egg, and then bring the opposite corner into the center. Pinch firmly together to seal the corners (make sure to do this, or your bow-ties will open up in the oven). Transfer cookie to cookie sheet and repeat the process with the remaining dough.
  • 6. Bake one sheet at a time until lightly browned on the bottoms and puffed, 10 to 12 minutes. Transfer to a rack to cool completely and then dust with powdered sugar.
  • 7. These cookies can be frozen in a sealed container for up to 3 months.

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating

28 thoughts on “NYC Cookie Swap Re-Cap and Jam Filled Bow Tie Cookies”

  1. Pingback: Healthy Green Kitchen Cold Asian Noodle Salad and In The Small Kitchen Giveaway!
  2. Pingback: Psycho Holiday Baking: Take 2! | Nicole's Nutrition
  3. Pingback: Sunday Sweets | Marie, Oh Marie
  4. I’ve never been to a swap myself, but if I ever get an invite, I’m bringing you along because you make cookies that I’d REALLY want to swap for! – S

  5. Ooooh, these look yummy, and so beautiful. The event sounds like a lot of fun, I’d love to get involved in a group like this with other NYC food bloggers!

  6. So much fun. I’ve done smaller ones before and variety has always been amazing. Thanks for the photo journey. My mother makes the jam filled cookies and they don’t last long!


  7. Your bow ties are almost too beautiful to eat! I think these are some of the prettiest Christmas cookies I’ve seen this season (and I’ve seen quite a few!) What a fun event! I’m sure it was great to chat with all these talented bloggers, and then to partake in all the sugary goodness! Thank you for sharing with me. I hope you have a Wednesday full of wonder and joy!

  8. I love that you have a jam you never got around to blogging about! (peach rosemary! yum!)

    Looking forward to your ginger gluten free recipe–will share with my friend who just found out she had celiac’s.

    PS. gluten-full. ha.

    • I’ve got tons of recipes that never make it to the blog!
      Will post the ginger bar recipe tomorrow, hopefully :)

  9. It was great meeting you last week. I tasted both cookies and they were both very delicious. The jam-filled bow ties cookies were especially festive for the holidays. They were just so cute and tasty!

    • Chris from The Peche and Abby Dodge are top center, and there were a bunch of food52 folks there: front and center above is Cathy (Mrs Wheelbarrow), top right is Phoebe and Cara from Big Girls, Small Kitchen, bottom right is Jennifer Perillo. Cookbook author Silvana Nardone is middle right…

  10. Those cookies are absolutely stunning! So fun to read your post about the cookie swap since I couldn’t make it myself. Saw lots of familiar faces in your photos. :)

    • I was worried they’d be homely compared to the other cookies in attendance, but everyone thought they were pretty, which make me happy :)

  11. What a fun event, cookie swapping! :) Love that idea! Your cookies turned out beautiful, just perfect. I love how you used homemade rosemary infused peach jam, now that sounds incredible.